09 December 2007

China Smaller than Previously Thought

Seems like an unbelievable headline, doesn't it? But that's essentially what the New York Times's Eduardo Porter is reporting today about the Chinese economy. Thanks to a massive statistical error, and correction, the Chinese economy turns out to be substantially smaller than previously thought:

"According to new estimates, the colossal Chinese economy that has been making marketers salivate and giving others an inferiority complex may be roughly 40 percent smaller than previously thought: worth $6 trillion rather than $10 trillion. That means it lost a chunk roughly the size of Japan’s output."

Porter goes on to note some of the consequences of this revision, including a tripling of the Chinese poverty rate. I can understand the generally difficulties in estimating the economic output of a relative closed country, but, in light of over-estimation of the USSR's economic output in the 1980s, I wonder if there's a tendency to over-estimate communist nations' economic output...

1 comment:

Unknown said...

im not sure it would be fair to make that generalization.

one of the problems with emerging markets in general is understanding the formal v. informal sector size